Skip to content

Call answering service or AI receptionist: how to choose

A call answering service usually puts a person on your line; an AI receptionist handles calls with software set up to follow rules you approve. Here is how the two can compare for a small business. We connect your phone numbers and help set up how an AI receptionist handles the inbound and outbound calls on them.

Updated

Virtual receptionist, AI receptionist and other names

Suppliers use these names in different ways, so the label alone may not tell you who answers your phone.

  • Call answering service

    Also sold as a telephone answering service. Typically the person answers in your business's name, then takes a message, follows a script you have agreed or passes the call to someone on your team, working within the hours on your plan.

  • Virtual receptionist

    Usually the same arrangement under another name: a person working away from your premises who acts as your front desk. Given the access, they may also book appointments or transfer calls. Some suppliers use the phrase for software, so ask which one you are being offered.

  • AI receptionist

    Software that is set up to handle a call from information your team has approved, in the hours you choose, and to pass the call to a person when a question falls outside it. Some suppliers sell this as an AI phone answering service.

  • Voicemail with call-back

    Nobody answers live. The caller leaves a message and someone at your firm rings back, so the caller waits for the reply.

  • Telling them apart

    A useful question is who answers and what they are allowed to do. A person can often use judgement within the script and the hours of the plan. Software is usually set up to apply the rules your team approved and to pass anything outside them to a named person. A label such as telephone answering service may say where a supplier sells, not what happens on the call.

What your caller hears with each

A live person sounds like one, and an AI receptionist is set up to tell the caller it is automated. The two tend to differ most at the five moments below.

Five moments in one call, compared
MomentWith a personWith an AI receptionist
The greeting Usually spoken in your business's name, in the wording you agree. Typically opens by saying the caller is speaking to an automated assistant. We design our set-up to include that disclosure.
A routine question Usually answered from the script and notes you supply, with a message taken if the question is not covered. Designed to answer from the facts your team has approved, such as hours, location and preparation, and to pass other questions to a person with a short note. How well this works depends on what your team has approved.
A booking request Often the details are taken for your team to enter. Booking into your diary depends on the supplier and the access you give. Bookings depend on your booking platform and on the permissions that have been checked. Where a booking cannot be made, the request is usually passed to a person to place.
An upset caller Someone can often hear distress, apologise and stay on the line, and may ring an on-call contact if you have agreed that. The assistant is not designed to assess urgency or give advice. A caller who asks for a person, or whose call matches a rule you set, is usually passed to a named person, or a message is taken where a live transfer is not possible.
A call outside opening hours Depends on the plan, because cover may be priced and scripted differently. Within the hours you choose, it is typically set up to answer a short list of routine questions, take a message or offer your booking link. It is not designed to assess urgency.
  • Write the greeting down

    Whichever you choose, write the greeting down and approve it before it goes live. Both depend on the notes behind them: the script for a person, the approved answers for the assistant.

  • Decide what after hours means

    Consider whether a caller out of hours should get a message, a booking link or an answer, and who reads the messages first in the morning.

Which costs less: an answering service or AI?

Which costs less depends on how many calls you get, how long they run and when they arrive, so it is worth comparing quotes for your own calls.

How each charge is built
ChargeWhere you meet itWhat to check
Per call or per minute A person-based service Long calls and busy spells can raise the bill. A firm with many short calls and a firm with a few long ones may not pay the same at the same rate.
Monthly bundle A person-based service What counts towards the bundle, what happens if you go over it and what a change to your script costs. A month with a spike can cost more than the bundle suggested.
Set-up fee Our AI receptionist Our set-up is charged as an implementation fee, published on the pricing page and not repeated here. In general it covers mapping your number and provider, agreeing the approved answers and the handover rules, and testing each path before go-live.
Running costs Our AI receptionist Charges from your phone provider and any voice or messaging usage typically depend on your plan and volume, and we aim to itemise them.
  • Which call patterns suit which

    Many short, similar calls often suit answers written down once. Fewer, longer or more sensitive calls often suit a person. Calls that vary sit between the two, and some firms use both.

  • Costs that are easy to miss

    Ask each supplier about a minimum term, a charge for changing the script or the approved answers, storage of recordings and messages, and the cost of moving a phone number.

Calls you may want a person to take

Some calls are often better taken by a person, whichever option you choose.

  • Distress or a complaint

    A caller who is upset about something that has already gone wrong often wants someone who can take responsibility for the answer. A script may not be able to do that, and taking a message may not help, because the caller may want a decision.

  • Clinical or legal questions

    A question about a diagnosis, a treatment, a case or a contract is usually best put to a qualified person. This guide is not legal advice, and a script reader or an assistant is not a substitute for one.

  • Urgent or safety-related calls

    These usually need a route to a person that you choose in advance, such as an on-call number. The assistant is not designed to assess urgency. It is set up to pass the call on by the route your team chooses, and the same route is worth having for a person who answers for you.

  • A caller who asks for a person

    A caller's request to speak to a person is usually the deciding factor. A good set-up passes the call on smoothly, or says honestly that nobody is free and takes a message. Whether a call can be passed on live depends on your phone system. Our AI receptionist page describes our usual approach.

  • Decisions for the owner

    Discounts, exceptions, refunds and anything that commits the firm's money or reputation are usually best left to someone with the authority to decide.

  • Messages that need a reply

    Both options can take messages, but someone on your team still needs to read each one and reply, so decide who that is before the first message arrives.

Questions for a call answering service or AI supplier

It helps to put the same questions to each supplier and write the answers down, because terms can differ between a UK telephone answering service, a virtual receptionist service and an AI phone answering service.

Questions to put to each kind of supplier
TopicAsk a person-based serviceAsk an AI supplier
The phone number Do calls reach you by forwarding from a number you own, or on a number the supplier holds? If the supplier holds it, what happens to it when you leave? Whose name are the phone number, the accounts and the approved answers held in, and what do you receive if you leave?
Contract and notice What is the minimum term and the notice period, and what do you take with you when you go? What notice period applies on either side?
Messages, recordings and data What personal data does a call produce (audio, a transcript, the caller number, a message)? Who holds it, how long is it kept, who at the supplier can read it and where is it stored? Ask for the answers in writing. What is recorded and what is written down? Who holds it, how long is it kept, who can read it and where is it stored?
When it cannot help What does the person do with a question the script does not cover, and who is rung when a call is urgent? Where are the people who answer based? A service sold to UK customers may not answer from the UK. What does the caller hear, who receives the message and what happens when a transfer is not answered? Ask whether each path has been tested.
Changing the answers What does a change to the script cost? Who writes the approved answers, who approves a change, and are changes after go-live in the price or quoted separately?
  • Recordings and what callers are told

    In our usual set-up, we do not keep call audio or transcripts by default. Recording is a separate scope to be agreed with you, and callers are told when a call is recorded.

  • Personal data and the rules that may apply

    Calls usually involve personal data, so UK GDPR, the Data Protection Act 2018 and, for marketing calls and messages, the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR) may apply. We help you meet these requirements with standard settings for cookie notices and consent, how long data is kept, who can read it and what callers are told, and we adapt data handling and cookie notices to the places where your customers are. We make no promise of a result.

Using both, or neither

Many firms can keep an existing service and add an AI receptionist, if they agree who takes which calls and who owns the messages. Some firms may need neither.

  • Decide who answers first

    It helps to split the calls by hours or by situation. For example, people take opening hours and the assistant handles overflow or the hours the office is closed. Writing the split down in hours and call types usually avoids confusion.

  • Agree the handover

    For each type of call, it helps to say which side takes it, who the other side passes it to and what the caller is told. Where a call cannot pass live between the two, the assistant is usually set up to tell the caller so and take a message.

  • Keep one message list and one set of facts

    Keep messages from both sides in one place, with one named person who reads them and replies. Keep opening hours, how to book and what to do in an emergency the same on both sides, and change both on the same day.

  • Read your contract first

    If you already use a service like this, read the term and the notice period before you add anything, and ask whether sending some calls elsewhere changes your plan.

  • Review the call log after a month

    After a month, compare the log with what each side took and which questions neither could answer, then consider moving a call type from one side to the other.

  • If you want people on the line

    Our AI receptionist set-up is a different service from a call answering service with people on the line. If a service with people on the line looks like a better fit for you, for some or all of your calls, we aim to say so.

  • When neither is needed

    A message sent after a missed call, a clearer voicemail greeting, one more part-time hire or a feature of your phone system or booking platform that you already pay for may be enough. It is a smaller step than either option. Our missed-call recovery page covers that step.

Frequently asked questions

Direct answers to the questions owners most often ask when they compare the two.

How much does a UK telephone answering service cost? A call answering service is typically charged per call, per minute or as a monthly bundle with an allowance, so your bill follows how many calls you get and how long they run.

A call answering service is typically charged per call, per minute or as a monthly bundle with an allowance, so your bill follows how many calls you get and how long they run. Ask each supplier to price the same week of your own calls, and ask what a minute over the bundle, cover outside office hours and a change to your script each cost.

How does an AI receptionist answer a phone line? An AI receptionist answers a call with software: the call reaches it by forwarding from your number or another route set up for you, and it replies only from answers your team has approved, saying first that it is automated.

An AI receptionist answers a call with software: the call reaches it by forwarding from your number or another route set up for you, and it replies only from answers your team has approved, saying first that it is automated. You choose the hours it covers, such as overflow while your team is busy or closed hours, and it books into your diary where your booking platform allows it.

What happens when an AI receptionist cannot answer? It passes the call to a named person by the route you chose, or tells the caller so and takes a message when a live transfer is not possible.

It passes the call to a named person by the route you chose, or tells the caller so and takes a message when a live transfer is not possible. The named person gets a short note of what was asked, and your team can add the missing answer to the approved set so the same question is handled next time.

Is a virtual receptionist a real person or software? A virtual receptionist is most often a real person working remotely and answering in your business name, although some suppliers use the label for software.

A virtual receptionist is most often a real person working remotely and answering in your business name, although some suppliers use the label for software. Ask whether a person is on the line during your hours and what the caller hears when a question falls outside the script.

Can I keep my phone number with a call answering service or an AI receptionist? Yes, if calls reach the supplier by forwarding from a number you own, because the number stays yours; if the supplier holds the number, you may lose it when you leave.

Yes, if calls reach the supplier by forwarding from a number you own, because the number stays yours; if the supplier holds the number, you may lose it when you leave. Before you sign, ask which arrangement is offered, what happens to a supplier-held number on exit and whether moving a number between phone providers is inside the quote, which it is not in our base set-up.

Will callers know they are speaking to an AI? Our set-up is designed to tell callers at the start of the call that they are speaking to an automated assistant, and your team approves that wording before go-live.

Our set-up is designed to tell callers at the start of the call that they are speaking to an automated assistant, and your team approves that wording before go-live. Ask any other supplier the same question, and ask to hear a test call before you commit.

Seven checks before you choose

It can help to answer these from your own call log for a typical week before you speak to any supplier.

  1. 1.How many calls went unanswered, and on which days and at which hours?
  2. 2.How many of the calls you did take were routine questions with the same answer each time?
  3. 3.How many needed a person's judgement, such as a complaint, a sensitive question or an exception?
  4. 4.How many came in outside opening hours, and what did those callers want?
  5. 5.Who holds the phone number and the phone account today?
  6. 6.What is one missed call worth to the firm, in your own figures?
  7. 7.What notice period would each option tie you to?

This guide is general information. It describes our usual approach to an AI receptionist, as set out on the AI receptionist page and the pricing page, and it names no supplier and quotes no market prices. Outcomes depend on the information and set-up involved, and each supplier's terms are worth checking. Compliance with data-protection and electronic-communications rules remains the business's own responsibility.

Bring your number and the calls you cannot take

Tell us which number customers ring, which calls your team cannot take and who could take a transfer. If something you already have, or a service with people on the line, looks like a better fit for you, we aim to say so.